These words have been sitting in the back of my brain since our discussion and i really became interested after reading lu s article from silence to words. Minzhan lu is the endowment professor of the humanities at drake university. Minzhan lu s treatment of language in from silence to words. Contexts for critical reading and writing 5th edition 9780321122209 by diana george and john trimbur for up to 90% off at. Extensive practice in literary analysis and in the forms and conventions of writing about various literary genres. Writing as struggle 2 in her article, from silence to words. In minzhan lous from silence to words, she describe the struggle of growing.
It is remarkable that lu had the same emotions around this issue, but her experience was the exact opposite. I feel the paragraph that best exemplifies this struggle is one found on page 23. Readings materializing transligualism department of. An interesting essay that could be used as an example of a literacy narrative. Minzhan lu is currently considered a single author. Min zhan lu is the author of writing conventions 4. Plus easytounderstand solutions written by experts for thousands of other textbooks. Well use our time inclass to do a closereading of minzhan lu s essay that you accessed via the hofstra librarys online database. Writing conventions teaches the fundamentals of writing by inviting students to reflect on their own experiences as writers and to explore new strategies for a variety of academic writing projects. The authors main point in this piece brings to light the internal struggle of. Both of these women experience literacy sponsorship1, although it presents itself in very different ways.
Not only have i learned about the curriculum but also about myself as a student. From silence to words by min zhan lu is about a chinese girl that matures and unlocks the key of her identity through language alone. This article examines mina shaughnessys errors and expectations in light of current discourse theories which posit language as a site of struggle among competing discourses. Through this essay, minzhan lu depicts the struggles she faced growing up in china while speaking english. If one or more works are by a distinct, homonymous authors, go ahead and split the author. Minzhan lus from silence to words response literacy.
I find annotating a book or story is much easier than annotating an article. Writing as struggle, by minzhan lu, she struggles to discern between two language discourses she grows up with, the one she is expected to use at school and the one she is expected to use at home. Writing as struggle an issue seen in american culture is fear of expression for different cultures in certain areas. Writing as a struggle, writer minzhan lu argues that, through her experience with languages as a child, she was able to learn the value of struggle in developing both ones personal voice, and that such struggles offer individuals. Writing as struggle, she begins with this paper is my attempt to fill up that silence with words, words i didnt have then, words that i have since come to by reflecting on my earlier experience as a student in china and on my recent experience as a composition teacher in the united states 437. The ideology of conflict in minzhan lus conflict and struggle subordinates. The struggle of writing thursday, december 17, 2015. Aimed at teachers of english, the essay takes a narrative stance, using minzhan lu s own experience growing up in china during a period of radical change. They also set up the stakes for lu writing this piece and for students who feel torn between linguistic traditions. Sep 11, 2016 minzhan lus from silence to words response posted on september 11, 2016 september, 2016 by jgabrielsenblog page 9 i began to see my parents choice of a family language as an antirevolutionary act and was alarmed that i had participated in such an act. Writing as struggle june jordan, nobody mean more to me than you and the future life of willie jordan wired culture. This article examines mina shaughnessys errors and expectations in light of current discourse theories which posit language as. Writing as struggle writing across borders documentary language, identity, and power.
Free essays on min zhan lu from silence to words writing as. Given these concerns, bruce horner, minzhan lu, and paul kei matsudas collection is an important contribution to the field. Issues in language diversity are rarely given attention in the firstyear composition classroom, but these essays reveal the benefits of this topic to all composition classes. The classroom and the wider culture the evergreen state college. Minzhan lu books biography and list of works author. Writing as struggle june jordan, nobody mean more to me than you and the future life of willie jordan wired culturepowerpoint. Writing as strugglethey set the tone for this personal academic essay in college english. Bruce horner, minzhan lu, jacqueline jones royster and john trimbur. More than 160 readings in conversations, fourth edition, present an extraordinary variety of authors, genres, voices, and viewpoints on important contemporary civic issues. Posted on september 11, 2016 september, 2016 by jgabrielsenblog. Revisiting the legacy of minzhan lu lu began to develop her theoretical framework through autobiographic work. The politics of style in the contact zone minzhan lu. Approved for the arts and sciences upperlevel requirement in written communication wr.
Shitty first drafts for this writing assignment, select one of the essays from the list of readings above, read this essay you select and write a. Lu, minzhan representing eric us department of education. Minzhan lu redefining the legacy of mina shaughnessy. Reveals how the frustration and confusion the author experienced growing up caught between. Assignment 22 corbin 1 kellie corbin mr hammond eng 101. Writing as a struggle, writer minzhan lu argues that, throughout her many different language learning experiences as a child, it enabled her to learn the value of struggle in developing both personal voice, and a greater knowledge of learning. Writing as a struggle, discusses her struggle with her voice in her life and education. Writing as struggle by minzhan lu minzhan lu, professor, department of english, university of louisville well use our time inclass to do a closereading of minzhan lu s essay that you accessed via the hofstra librarys online database. Writing as struggle, she explains the consequences of living between two different worlds.
My focus shifted from literacy as my main focus to the readers, the literates, if you will. The mercury reader pearson learning solutions mafiadoc. Writing as struggle, she describes her childhood experiences growing up in communist china and her many literacy sponsors. Martins guide to teaching writing with cheryl glenn, surveying the literary landscapes of terry tempest williams with katherine chandler, and the norton pocket book of writing by students. The chinese standard speaking occurs within the school setting and is used by her teachers and classmates.
One of the biggest literacy sponsors lu had were her parents. An analysis of the narrative from silence to words. Mostly because a stories are progressive so as the story builds you know what lines are significant or what scenes define the story. Her work has appeared in college english, writing on the edge, reader, and in numerous books. Writing as struggle imagine that you enter a parlor. Chinese poetry in english verse full audiobook youtube. Writing as struggle is interesting in that she describes a process during which acquiring language leads to a deepening silence. Writing as struggle, she explains how being bilingual and speaking two different languages at home and at school put her at a great disadvantage throughout life. Min zhan lu redefining the legacy of mina shaughnessy. Writing as a struggle, she details her life growing up in communist china. In deborah brandts essay sponsors of literacy, she discusses sarah steele, who worked as a secretary.
Silence and expression through language as cool as mint. From silence to words 1 from silence to words minzhan lu. An essay or paper on essay analysis on from silence to words. I feel the paragraph that best exemplifies this struggle is one found on page 239. English was seen and promoted as a language of immense possibilities at her home, drawing examples from the failure of a.
New mla sample entries and homework for thursday the daily. Free essays on min zhan lu from silence to words writing. Minzhan lu teaches in the english department at the university of pittsburgh, where she is completing a dissertation on literary practice in chicago in the 1890s. For my freshmen year first semester courses i feel that i have learned many new things. Growing up in a society dominated by mao tsetungs marxism, lu grew up with speaking english in her home and standard chinese, the language of new china. In from silence to words, she describes her experiences as a chinese student in maoist china coming from a household that attempted to instill in her a western humanistic tradition through the teaching of european. Analytical summary english class essay example topics. She spoke english with her parents at home, and standard chinese at school. Literary analysis from silence to words writing as struggle. Writing as struggle a186 david ludlum, the climythology of america a234 alison lurie, american regional costume a121 niccolo machiavelli, of the things for which men, and especially princes, are praised or blamed a122 alistair macleod, the boat a605 nancy mairs, on being a cripple a055. Apr 02, 2017 marjorie agosin is a professor of spanish at wellesley college as well as an essayist, poet, and human rights activist. Hammond eng 101 assignment 22 in from silence to words. Minzhan lu university of louisville follow this and additional works at. In minzhan lu s piece from silence to words she talks at one point about her second grade homeroom teacher.
Symposium on basic writing, conflict and struggle, and the. View essay from silence to words from engl 101 at college of western idaho. Minzhan lu response post group b in minzhan lu s piece from silence to words. You listen for a while, until you decide that you have caught the tenor of the argument. The crossings of four women of china, minzhan lu pittsburgh. Download books 5 book crosslanguage relations in composition.
Writing as struggle time goes by, maybe one day the truth will disappear in the historys sand drift. Writing as a struggle in her article, from silence to words. Lawrence summers, remarks on diversifying the science and engineering workforce. From then on, i took care not to use english outside home and to. Silence is a fortress, a means of defense, a retreat from the confusing world of multiculturalism.
My mother withdrew into silence two months before she died. A few nights before she fell silent, she told me she regretted the way she had raised me and my. But we are still very happy to share what we have learned with every of you. The silencer in the narrative from silence to words. Minzhan lu biography minzhan lu biography and list of works minzhan lu books.
The politics of critical affirmation center for writing. Apr 02, 2017 these are the opening lines of minzhan lus from silence to words. Page 9 i began to see my parents choice of a family language as an antirevolutionary act and was alarmed that i had participated in such an act. She was born into a world of clashing cultures and studied both chinese as well as english. Sep 11, 2011 the person, the educator who hands over the gun, hands over the bullets the perspective, and must own up to the consequences 39. Available late winter 2020 questions and assignments available pending clearance bedford select a custom database essays fiction poetry drama images instructional materials. They sent her to a local private school to learn how to speak, read, and write in a new languagestandard. Writing as struggle paul roberts, how to say nothing in 500 words cause and effect. In the essay always living in spanish, translated by celeste kostopuloscooperman, and the poem english, translated by monic bruno, agosin. The enrichment approach to language and literacy, sponsored in part by the fund for the improvement of. Cooper, michigan technological university in the symposium on the politics of the personal published in college english in september 2001, minzhan lu suggests that to break down. Minzhan lu and bruce horner, thirty year ncte veterans, have coauthored. It helped to form a bond between the two of them and they would learn from each other. Minzhan lus from silence to words response literacy in.
These words have been sitting in the back of my brain since our discussion and i really became interested after reading lus article from silence to words. Relates the authors reflections on her early experiences as a student in china and her recent experiences as a composition teacher in the united states. Writing as struggle recounts the way the was torn between two cultures linguistically, in her years of growing up in a semi postcapitalist, semi postcolonial china. Richard rodriguez, public and private language deborah tannen, men and women talking on the job process analysis introduction gloria anzaldua, how to tame a wild tongue jared diamond, the ethnobiologists dilemma min. Writing as struggle, she talks about her struggles with the use of language in different situations and her familys struggles during the cultural revolution. Crosslanguage relations in composition, edited by bruce. Writing as struggle, by min zhan lu, lu talks about forming a voice even throughout the struggles of being a part of two opposite worlds socially, linguistically, and influentially. Writing as struggle, minzhan lu states, i remember that we were moved by jane eyre when she was torn between her sense of ethics, which compelled her to leave the man she loved, and her impulse to stay with the only man who had ever loved her, 383. The politics of critical affirmation minzhan lu drake university a lecture sponsored by the center for interdisciplinary studies of writing and the minor in composition, literacy, and rhetorical studies a version of this paper also appears in the december, 1999 issue of. Unlike me, it was antirevolutionary to even contain english inside any parts of your brain. These are the opening lines of minzhan lu s from silence to words. Gloria anzaldua, how to tame a wild tongue amy tan, mother tongue nancy schniedewind and ellen davidson, linguicism clyde w.
You listen for a while, until you decide that you have caught the. Acclaimed for its compelling readings and provocative images, reading cultureprovides outstanding instruction on how to read and write critically about the culture that surrounds us. Writing as struggle through this essay, minzhan lu depicts the struggles she faced growing up in china while speaking english. For example, the word ideal often functions as an adjective meaning perfect in casual conversation, whereas academics sometimes use the word ideal to indicate. Writing as a struggle, writer minzhan lu argues that, through her experience with languages as a child, she was able to learn the value of struggle in developing both ones personal voice, and that such struggles offer individuals a greater knowledge of language and its use as a vehicle for ideas. Minzhan lu analytical response writing 01 portfolio. An analysis of from silence to words, sample of essays. Unit 1 the superfantastic writing college, writing life. Writing as struggle she is talking about being apart of two worlds, the chinese standard speaking and the english western speaking that occurs at home. Revolutionary act lu 20 and she began to conceal her knowledge of it after. Part of the english language and literature commons, and the rhetoric and composition commons original publication information lu, minzhan. Minzhan lu, professor, department of english, university of louisville.
Extensive practice in literary analysis and in the forms. Lu had to protect herself and her intellectual family by not revealing her knowledge of the english language. When you arrive, others have long preceded you, and they are engaged in a heated dis cussion. Check out our top free essays on min zhan lu from silence to words writing as struggle to help you write your own essay. Lu had this special connection with her teacher where they would speak english together.
761 174 309 697 993 175 631 824 1461 1047 8 990 951 29 984 965 1017 1348 1137 404 40 63 1254 640 1316 634 1278 842 877 1304 132 293